- The Kumul 23 police unit is believed to be responsible for the deaths of eight people and numerous house burnings in Porgera, near the Porgera Gold Mine.
- Among the dead was a 16-year-old boy, Richard Yope, whose father says he was caught in the crossfire.
- The district administrator says the mine owner and the state are seeking to crack down on illegal mining, but efforts to resettle local villagers are problematic.
Eight dead in September massacre at PNG’s troubled Porgera
Details are emerging of a late September massacre at Porgera Valley in Papua New Guinea’s Enga Province, where eight people were allegedly killed by officers with PNG’s Kumul 23 elite tactical police unit.
It has raised serious concerns about ongoing efforts to target illegal miners at the Porgera gold mine, which has been a magnet for lawlessness and violence for decades.
In the early hours of 23 September, Kumul 23 unit officers drove through villages on and adjacent to the Porgera mine site – the villages of Kulapi 1 through Kulapi 4 – setting fire to houses and reportedly firing indiscriminately into a crowd of rounded-up villagers.
Porgera District administrator Jerry Maku confirmed that eight people are known to have been killed, with one critically injured.
RNZ Pacific has seen footage – taken at the end of that day – of bodies adorned with blankets and flowers, surrounded by grieving locals. In the footage, a voice says in Tok Pisin that “all our houses have been burned down” and that “many of our tribesmen are missing”.
Maku said that six people spotted near the Porgera gold mine, suspected of being illegal miners, were shot and killed by police officers, while two landowners were killed in their homes.
It is the latest incident in a long string of violence linked to efforts to relocate people who have been living on or near the Special Mining Lease (SML) area.
The owners of the mine, mining company Barrick Niugini Limited and the PNG state, have been trying to crack down on ongoing illegal mining at the mine site, but the ensuing displacement of local villagers has added to the problems.
“Frightening things are happening, and we are failing, the government is failing its own people,” Maku said.
“They have no place to go, that’s why they are just hanging around with illegal miners… but you know, they start shooting.”
Teenager killed, police refusing to allow burial
Richard Yope, a 16-year-old student, is reported to be among those killed in the incident. According to his family, he was simply passing by the area.
A letter written by Pulumani Tribe spokesperson Andreas Wabiria, addressed to authorities and supplied to RNZ Pacific, said the officers were wearing military fatigue uniforms and black masks covering their faces.
“They ordered villagers to assemble, razed Kulapi Villages 1, 2, 3 and 4, burnt houses belonging to Pulumani Tribe landowners, and discharged firearms indiscriminately into the crowd.
“Many other persons remain missing and are presumed dead,” Wabiria said.
Enga Province has been plagued by violence for years – both election-related conflict and tribal fighting.
Screengrab / supplied
Afterwards, officers cordoned off areas of the district and formed a roadblock on the Highlands Highway towards Mount Hagen, whose hospital had been willing to autopsy bodies.
Wabiria said it stopped most relatives of the deceased from taking the bodies for post-mortem examination – but they managed to get Richard out.
Thirty family members accompanied Richard’s mother Rachel to Mount Hagen General Hospital, a four-hour drive from Porgera, where they still remain.
Wabiria told RNZ Pacific they were told over the phone by Maku on Saturday that officers were refusing to let them return with Richard’s body for the sake of a traditional burial at the village.
“I couldn’t really help them much, because Kumul 23 is going to get on me if I try to,” Maku told RNZ Pacific.
Wabiria said that many in the group feared for their lives if they re-approached the entrance to their homes.
“This is two deaths in two years suffered by the same family, at the hands of the same mine, under the watch of the same government… they are becoming a spectator on their own land.”
“The morgue fees is also exorbitant, every day it costs her dearly to keep the body in the morgue,” he said.
“All 30 of them, they are hungry. They have no whatever means of surviving.”
“They shoot anybody”
Enga Province has been plagued by violence for years – both election-related conflict and tribal fighting.
Lawlessness in and around Porgera, particularly in relation to illegal mining, has also been a problem that Engan authorities have struggled to contain over many years.
“The company doesn’t want illegal miners to stay close to the mine, every day they go in and disturb the mine operation,” Maku said.
“They suspect that the landowners are harbouring the illegal miners.”
Earlier this year, Enga’s governor Sir Peter Ipatas told RNZ Pacific that people in his province had taken lawlessness to another level using modern guns, with no respect for authority.
The national government has responded to the problem by resourcing police on the ground. In recent months, Kumul 23 intensified its ground patrols across Enga as part of operations targeting illegal firearms and violent offenders, and as part of an intelligence-led policing strategy.
The unit was established last year, in the wake of new anti-terrorism laws in PNG – its forces were given unprecedented ‘shoot to kill’ powers.
PNG’s former Deputy Prime Minister Don Polye, an influential Engan political leader, said he had concerns from the outset about the use of the ‘terrorism’ tag in a PNG context.
The latest events have deeply concerned Polye who told RNZ Pacific that a grieving father had approached him about the death of his teenage son.
“The father who lives in Port Moresby, he came to me crying. I said what happened. He said ‘my son has been killed and murdered’… he said ‘it was the police that shot my son’.
Polye said it was difficult to reconcile how this boy from Kandep High School could have been targeted. Polye said the boy had gone to Porgera to get some money off his uncle to make provisions ahead of exams – as is normal practice – but got caught in the crossfire.
“Kumul 23 just went in and burned down houses and started shooting at this line of houses and this compound, that the intelligence told them that they were illegal miners.”
“They started shooting at them, and some of them were running. And one student who I know personally, he went into the wrong direction, and the Kumul 23 shot him and he died.”
“So Kumul 23 goes in and they shoot anybody.”
Failure in resettlement efforts
Polye said in the absense of a proper relocation plan, a volatile mix of different communities has increased in Porgera while associated law and order problems have grown out of control.
“There is the soup of locals, immigrants, illegal miners, warlords, warriors, mercenaries – all squatting on the SML land,” Polye explained.
“For addressing the 30 years of outstanding SML relocation issues, funding will have to have been provided.”
“When no such relocation is taking place and (with) the gold price being at the highest peak in history, the SML area is breeding the chaos witnessed in Porgera at present.”
Wabiria said the Pulumani tribe were seeking just restitution from the government, noting a 700 million-kina budget set aside for the relocation of his people that thus far has been untouched.
The deal – which has yet to be settled between landowners and Prime Minister James Marape – included more than K200 million in ‘equity-related’ funding that is currently being held in a government trust.
Marape could start by rebuilding the houses that the violence has destroyed, Wabiria suggested.
“They should just have the courtesy and the respect, the human dignity, to at least bury the dead and facilitate the land.”
He added that as things stand, once the 30 locals return from Mount Hagen, none of them will have a home to go to.
RNZ Pacific has sought comment from the PNG Constabulary, the national government, and Enga Province governor Sir Peter Ipatas.
